Hey pizza lovers! Craving that authentic New York slice right here in St. Paul? You're in luck! We're diving deep into the best spots in the city where you can get your fix of thin crust, perfectly foldable, and deliciously cheesy New York-style pizza. Whether you're a longtime resident or just passing through, this guide will help you find your go-to pizzeria for a taste of the Big Apple, right in the heart of Minnesota.

What Makes New York Style Pizza Special?

Before we jump into the list, let's talk about what makes New York-style pizza so iconic. New York-style pizza is characterized by its large, wide slices with a thin, crispy crust that is foldable yet sturdy enough to hold the toppings. The dough is typically hand-tossed and made from high-gluten flour, which gives it that signature chewiness. The sauce is a simple blend of tomatoes, herbs, and spices, and the cheese is usually low-moisture mozzarella, applied generously but not overwhelmingly. The pizza is then baked in a deck oven at high temperatures, giving it that slightly charred and bubbly crust.

But what truly sets it apart? It's the combination of these elements that creates a pizza experience that's both satisfying and comforting. The perfect balance of flavors and textures—the crispiness of the crust, the tanginess of the sauce, the gooeyness of the cheese—all come together in each slice. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or something loaded with toppings, New York-style pizza offers something for everyone.

Moreover, the cultural significance of New York-style pizza cannot be overstated. It's more than just food; it's a part of New York's identity. From the bustling streets of Manhattan to the quiet corners of Brooklyn, pizza shops are a staple, serving up slices to hungry New Yorkers and tourists alike. This tradition has spread across the country, with pizzerias aiming to replicate the unique taste and experience of the original. In St. Paul, several establishments have taken on the challenge, striving to bring that authentic New York flavor to the Midwest.

Top Pizzerias in St. Paul for New York Style Pizza

Alright, let's get to the main event: where to find the best New York-style pizza in St. Paul. We've scoured the city, sampled countless slices, and compiled a list of the top pizzerias that truly capture the essence of New York-style pizza. Get ready to satisfy your cravings!

1. Mama's Pizza

First on our list is Mama's Pizza, a local favorite known for its commitment to traditional New York-style techniques. At Mama's, they pride themselves on using high-quality ingredients and time-tested recipes to create pizzas that are as close to the real deal as you can get in St. Paul. The dough is made fresh daily, hand-tossed to perfection, and topped with a tangy, flavorful sauce and generous amounts of mozzarella cheese. The pizzas are then baked in a deck oven, ensuring a crispy crust and perfectly melted cheese.

What makes Mama's stand out? It's their attention to detail and dedication to quality. From the selection of ingredients to the baking process, every step is carefully executed to ensure that each pizza is a masterpiece. Customers rave about the classic cheese pizza, praising its simplicity and perfect balance of flavors. But don't stop there—Mama's also offers a variety of toppings, from pepperoni and sausage to vegetables and specialty cheeses, allowing you to customize your pizza to your liking. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a great spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Plus, their delivery service is quick and reliable, so you can enjoy their delicious pizza from the comfort of your own home.

2. Sammy's Avenue Eatery

Next up, we have Sammy's Avenue Eatery. While Sammy's is known for its diverse menu of sandwiches and salads, their New York-style pizza is a hidden gem that's worth discovering. Sammy's takes a modern approach to the classic New York slice, using fresh, locally sourced ingredients to create pizzas that are both delicious and innovative. The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce is vibrant and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh and seasonal.

What sets Sammy's apart? Their commitment to using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. This not only supports local farmers and producers but also ensures that their pizzas are bursting with flavor. Sammy's offers a variety of specialty pizzas, such as the Margherita with fresh basil and tomatoes, and the Spicy Sausage with peppers and onions. They also have a build-your-own option, allowing you to create your perfect pizza with a wide selection of toppings. The atmosphere is casual and modern, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. And with multiple locations throughout St. Paul, you're never too far from a slice of Sammy's delicious pizza.

3. Pizza Luce

Pizza Luce is a well-known name in the Twin Cities, and for good reason. While they offer a variety of pizza styles, their New York-style pizza is a standout. Pizza Luce is committed to using organic and locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their New York-style pizza features a thin, crispy crust, a tangy tomato sauce, and a generous topping of mozzarella cheese. You can customize your pizza with a variety of toppings, including vegetarian and vegan options. Many people praise its robust sauce, perfectly cooked crust, and the freshness of the toppings.

What makes Pizza Luce special? Pizza Luce also stands out for its commitment to sustainability and community involvement. They source their ingredients from local farms and producers, and they participate in various community initiatives. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, making it a great spot for a night out with friends or family. And with multiple locations throughout the Twin Cities, Pizza Luce is a convenient option for anyone craving a delicious New York-style pizza.

4. Black Sheep Coal Fired Pizza

Black Sheep Coal Fired Pizza brings a unique twist to the New York-style pizza game. They use a coal-fired oven to cook their pizzas, giving them a distinctive smoky flavor and a perfectly charred crust. The pizzas are made with simple, high-quality ingredients, and the focus is on letting the flavors speak for themselves. The dough is made fresh daily, hand-tossed, and topped with a tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a variety of toppings.

What makes Black Sheep unique? It's their use of a coal-fired oven. The high heat of the oven creates a crispy, charred crust and a smoky flavor that you won't find anywhere else. Black Sheep offers a variety of specialty pizzas, such as the classic Margherita and the Fennel Sausage. The atmosphere is rustic and industrial, making it a great spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Be prepared for a slightly longer wait time, as the coal-fired oven takes time to work its magic, but trust us, it's worth it.

Tips for Enjoying Your New York Style Pizza

Okay, you've found your pizzeria, you've ordered your pizza—now what? Here are a few tips to help you make the most of your New York-style pizza experience:

• The Fold: The quintessential New York-style pizza move. Fold your slice lengthwise to create a sturdy, easy-to-handle wedge. This keeps the toppings from sliding off and allows you to enjoy the perfect balance of flavors in every bite.
• The Napkin: New York-style pizza can be a bit greasy, so don't be afraid to blot your slice with a napkin before folding. This helps to reduce the grease and makes it easier to handle.
• The Toppings: While a classic cheese pizza is always a good choice, don't be afraid to experiment with toppings. From pepperoni and sausage to vegetables and specialty cheeses, there are endless possibilities.
• The Drink: Pair your pizza with a classic New York beverage, such as a cold soda or a local beer. The carbonation helps to cut through the richness of the pizza and cleanse your palate.
• The Experience: Enjoy the experience! New York-style pizza is more than just food; it's a cultural icon. Take your time, savor each bite, and appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into making a great pizza.

Final Thoughts

So there you have it, folks! Your guide to finding the best New York-style pizza in St. Paul. Whether you're a longtime fan of the New York slice or a newcomer looking to try something new, we hope this list helps you discover your new favorite pizzeria. Remember, the perfect slice is out there, waiting to be found. Happy pizza hunting!